Judge overturns murder conviction in killing of Run‑DMC’s Jam Master Jay

A federal judge on Friday threw out the murder conviction of Karl Jordan Jr., one of two men found guilty in the 2002 killing of Run‑DMC legend Jam Master Jay. The ruling said prosecutors did not prove Jordan had a motive to shoot the pioneering DJ inside his Queens recording studio.

Federal Judge Rules Jam Master Jay Murder Evidence Failed to Show Motive

U.S. District Judge LaShann DeArcy Hall issued the decision nearly two years after a jury convicted Jordan and co‑defendant Ronald Washington, reports the Associated Press. The judge upheld Washington’s conviction.

Case Takes Another Unexpected Turn

The reversal marked another dramatic shift in a homicide investigation that stalled for almost 20 years. Authorities arrested Jordan and Washington in 2020, saying they finally had the witnesses and evidence needed to solve the killing of Jason “Jam Master Jay” Mizell.

Run‑DMC helped push hip‑hop into mainstream culture during the 1980s. Mizell’s death in 2002 came after the high‑profile shootings of Tupac Shakur and The Notorious B.I.G., deepening concerns about violence surrounding major rap figures.

Judge Says Motive Evidence Was Missing

During the trial, witnesses testified that Jordan fired the fatal shot and later admitted to the killing, per AP. Prosecutors argued that Jordan acted out of anger after a cocaine deal fell through. Yet Jordan’s attorneys said the government never showed why he would retaliate.

Hall agreed. She wrote that the evidence supported a motive for Washington, who allegedly lost access to a lucrative Baltimore drug pipeline. Witnesses said Washington blocked the studio door and ordered an aide to the ground during the shooting.

However, Hall said there was no proof that Jordan sought revenge for the failed deal. She ruled that the government’s theory did not meet the legal standard required to sustain the conviction.

Washington’s Conviction Remains Intact for Jam Master Jay Murder

The judge denied Washington’s request for an acquittal or a new trial. His attorneys argued that he had no reason to harm Mizell, a longtime friend who helped him financially and allowed him to stay with family members. Washington can continue to appeal.

Jordan’s defense also pointed to another suspect, Jay Bryant, who was charged in 2023. Prosecutors said Bryant’s DNA was found on a hat at the scene, and a relative testified that Bryant admitted to the shooting. Bryant has pleaded not guilty and awaits trial.

Drug Conspiracy Evidence Played Central Role

Prosecutors said Mizell allegedly turned to cocaine distribution as his music career slowed. They argued that Jordan and Washington worked with him in a trafficking network tied to Baltimore. Evidence reportedly showed Jordan was part of the conspiracy, but Hall ruled that participation alone did not prove motive for murder.

Jordan, who was 18 at the time, has said he was at his girlfriend’s home the night of the shooting. His attorneys said witnesses could support that account.