Justice Department closes investigation into Emmett Till killing, unable to prove witness lied

The Justice Department has officially closed its investigation into the killing of Emmett Till without federal charges for a second time, after failing to prove a key witness lied.

Emmett Till Investigation

Till, a Black teenager from Chicago, was brutally beaten and shot in the head in 1955 after a white woman, Carolyn Bryant Donham, said he whistled at her and touched her in a Mississippi store. He was only 14 at the time of his death.

J.W. Milam and Roy Bryant, Donham’s husband at the time, were acquitted of Till’s murder by an all-male, all-white jury in Mississippi that deliberated for just over an hour before it returned a not guilty verdict. Both men, who have since died, told a magazine journalist that they committed the crime, offering a detailed account of the gruesome slaying.

Witness Recants Story?

Deborah Watts, Till’s cousin, said in 2017 that investigators were looking into whether Donham admitted to lying about the incident.

Donham was reported to have recanted her story to the author Timothy B. Tyson, telling him she lied about the incident.

“Nothing that boy did could ever justify what happened to him,” she was alleged to have told Tyson while describing her “sorrow” for Till’s mother.

But Donham denied to federal investigators that she lied in her testimony, a source with knowledge of the case said, and there were inconsistencies with statements made by Tyson. Justice Department officials plan to release a memo after they brief Till’s family in Chicago, the source added.

Tyson stood by his reporting, describing Donham as unreliable in an emailed statement.

“Carolyn Bryant denies it and avoids talking about it like it was the plague,” he said. “I am standing in the public square telling the truth as I see it based on solid evidence.”

Till’s murder rocked the nation, becoming a catalyst for the civil rights movement. Thousands of people attended his funeral, where his mother insisted on an open casket to show the brutality of his killing.